In international law and business, patent trolling or patent hoarding is a categorical or pejorative term applied to a person or company that attempts to enforce patent rights against accused infringers far beyond the patents actual value or contribution to the prior art, often through hardball legal tactics frivolous litigation, vexatious litigation, strategic lawsuit against public participation slapp, chilling effects, and the like. Eff is currently fighting the patent troll personal audio at the patent office, where were arguing that u. Very often, the entities wielding software patents are patent trollscompanies that make money off suing and threatening to sue others. Patent filings show western district of texas is the new. I soon realized that all of these texas patent attorneys are in the same game with the patent trolls these attorneys make money the longer the legal process gets drawn out. Patent troll loses his papers outside the supreme court. One of which is that many of the patent trolls are focused on software patents or business process patents, which are harder to defend against and are only valid in the us. And it does not address the root cause of patent trolling. Theres a few things about the itc that make it an appealing place to bring a patent lawsuit if youre a patent troll. That represents a more than 60percent dropoff in new filings. Hublink, llc, a dominion harbor subsidiary, is also based in texas dominion harbor receives its patents from microsofts patent troll, intellectual ventures.
How east texas became the epicenter for patent troll. Patent trolls are in the business of patent litigation, enforcing their patent rights against alleged infringers through license fees and lawsuits. These rights are granted to patent applicants in exchange for their disclosure of the inventions. Plaintiffs in patent lawsuits used to flock to the eastern district. Supreme court decision deals blow to patent trolls and. A danish company fights a patent lawsuit in texas and wins. In the 90 days before tc heartland, 377 patent lawsuits were filed in the eastern district of texas. Hbos last week tonight highlighted an east texas citys role in infamous patent troll cases. Patent trolls, as host john oliver explains, are companies that. For well over a decade, weve discussed how patent trolls absolutely love to file cases in east texas, and in the past few years, gilstrap has basically been the. And its also bad news for the trolls longtime venue of choice, the eastern district of texas, where thousands of patent cases are brought each year 2,500 in 2015 alone. Patent trolls use a number of legal activities that. International trade, not interrupted tradetrolls and the.
Formed in january 2018 as a texas limited liability company, akoloutheo was assigned the rights. How one patent troll is desperately trying to stay in east texas. Unfortunately for marshall, tyler and other east texas towns, the torrent of lucrative patent litigationrelated business traffic may slow to a. But when patent trolls abuse the system by stockpiling patents and threatening lawsuits, businesses are forced to. Although independent users of linux and free and open source software have special concerns about the patent system, whitehurst said red hat is targeted by patent trolls because of its size and. Marshall, texas has been, and will likely continue to be, one of the major patent litigation cities in the united states. A patent troll is a company that exploits existing structural issues within the u. When patents attack the patent system has driven innovation for trolls score. Between 2001 and 2006, plaintiffs won 18 straight verdicts in marshall, according to texas monthly.
The us supreme court is reining in patent trolls, which is a win for. Over 5,000 firms were named as defendants in patent troll. In particular, the software industry differs from other major. But personal audio is also involved in litigation against podcasters and tv companies in the eastern district of texas. Texas ruling is vicarious victory for trolls by josh landau october 7, 2019 in a decision issued last week, judge gilstrapthe poster boy for patent trolls favorite court, the eastern district of texashas mangled the law on induced infringement, contributory. Supreme court makes it much harder for patent trolls to sue in east texas folks got sued in east texas just because they had a website. The eastern district of texas has been a particularly popular filing venue for patent trolls because of the districts fasttrack litigation procedures, favorable jury awards to patent holders. First, the only remedy the itc can give is an injunction. A software patent is a patent on a piece of software, such as a computer program, libraries, user interface, or algorithm. Npr reporter laura sydell and this american life producerplanet money cohost alex blumberg tell the story of intellectual ventures, which is accused of being the largest of the patent trolls. Patent troll akoloutheo sues oracle in latest chapter of. It probably hasnt made patent trolls go away, but its changed their demands, noted mark lemley, a law professor at stanford university. Sc ruling signals new era for software patent enforcement. The patent troll crisis is really a software patent crisis.
Supreme court ends texas grip on patent cases electronic. The patent troll crisis is really a software patent crisis thats because trolls are filing an unprecedented number of expensive lawsuits. Arguing that most judges dont have the technical expertise to preside over most software patent cases, predatory litigants have managed to shift more and more cases to a single federal court system. Patent and trademark office is testing new software that gives patent examiners additional tools to identify whether a patent application incorporates existing technology, uspto director.
Supreme court decision deals blow to patent trolls and the best. The american patent system continues to distribute monopolies on algorithms and some of these cause litigation to reach courts that are notorious for intolerance of 35 u. But in district court, trolls have a lot of difficulty getting injunctions. Patent trolls, as host john oliver explains, are companies that dont produce anything but shakedown those who do. Why it matters that patent trolls wont be able to force their cases in. While the federal government has exclusive jurisdiction over patent law, it has. In 1999, 14 patent cases were filed in the eastern district of texas. The patent trial and appeal board ptab, microsoft trolls, and the eastern district of texas. How to prepare now cloud computing, like any hot technology, has caught the eye of the patent trolls. The q1 2020 patent dispute report, now available on unifieds website, shows that the western district of texas is definitively the new hotspot for patent cases. The real toll of patent trolls patent trolls drain businesses of billions of dollars a year. The investigation takes them to a small town in texas, where they find a hallway full of empty companies with no employees.
Why patent trolls go to east texas, explained ars technica. Patent troll goes after facebook, apple, microsoft, yahoo. Patent trolls in texas take another hit marginal revolution. How one patent troll is desperately trying to stay in east texas ars. Patents are legal instruments that can be used to sue people and companies for creating, selling, or using software. The business model centers on buying patents and threatening litigation. Todays patent trolls are wreaking damage on a scale not seen in the past. Patent trolls are on the run, but not vanquished yet. The supreme court ruled that patent holders can no longer choose where to file infringement suits. In europe, patent trolls are much less of a problem for two reasons. The ruling will likely lead to a big growth in patent litigation in the district of delaware where many companies are incorporated. Software patents were described as particularly prone to abuse because. In 2016, marshall, texas with a population of only 24,000, was home to an astonishing 25 percent of all patent filings in the. Supreme court ruling bolsters zohos stand against patent.
In international law and business, patent trolling or patent hoarding is a categorical or. For decades, technology companies have been an easy target for frivolous patent suits. In its latest filing in february 2019, nonpracticing entity akoloutheo, llc has expanded its eastern district of texas patent litigation campaign to include oracle akoloutheo accuses the oracle analytics cloud, oracle exadata, and oracle data visualization technology as infringing on its patent. And if you have a websiteany websiteyou are a potential target. Patent trolls favorite judge comes up with test to keep.
Apple shutting down stores in east texas to avoid patent. In town that patent trolls built, supreme court ruling is. For nearly fifteen years, weve written about how patent trolls love east texas, and spent years building an entire industry in some small texas towns. Supreme court considers why patent trolls love texas the. All too often, software patents stop more innovation than they promote. Your developers need to avoid their day or month, or year. Supreme court makes it much harder for patent trolls to. The supreme courts big ruling on patent trolls will. Patent trolls began to flock there when a judge created local patent rules that were perceived as friendly to patent owners.
Patent trolls with weak cases can, of course, still file elsewhere. Yesterday, the supreme court dealt a major blow to patent trolls all across the u. For years, patent trolls like smartflash have chosen east texas towns like tyler, the site of this weeks jury verdict, where local judges and lawyers have built a cottage industry on patent litigation, drawing a stream of visiting lawyers to the towns hotels and restaurants. In recent years, patent trolls found a plaintifffriendly venue in the courts of east texas, which attract over 40% of all u. Hbos last week tonight highlighted an east texas city s role in infamous patent troll cases. The economic burden of todays patent lawsuits is, in fact, historically unprecedented. The patent process can be remade to serve invention and innovation again, if the trolls can be held at bay. Congress began implementing reforms to the patent system, states too have been considering measures to protect their residents and business from abusive patent litigation.
For more than ten years, patent troll litigation has clustered in the eastern district of texas edtx. After tc heartland, just 129 cases were filed in a similar period. Many patentholders stop looking to east texas following. Patent trolls are on the run, but not vanquished yet strong legislation that will weaken the ability of the trolls to shake down innovators is likely to pass congress, but more should be done. If you are interested, there was a great story on the radio regarding patent trolls and connections to east texas. The texas court is a favorite venue of patent trolls, or companies that buy patents not to use them but to demand royalties and sue for damages. The eastern district of texas has been a particularly popular filing venue for patent trolls because of the districts fasttrack litigation procedures, favorable jury awards to patent holders and its relatively remote location. Uspto testing ai software to help examiners id prior art. As many as 55% of all patent defendants and 82% of pae patent troll defendants have been sued on the basis of a software patent share of patent litigation defendants sued on the basis of a software patent. Videogame mouse firm offers lesson in how to beat a texas. For inventors, patents are an essential protection against theft. Videogame mouse firm offers lesson in how to beat a texas patent troll. Recent changes to patent law have made it easier to beat patent trolls, but it hasnt made the patent hotspot of east texas any quieter.
929 56 570 416 167 780 341 1417 976 1458 108 265 1069 1271 814 121 1415 1570 499 897 333 14 90 619 644 393 739 506 859 528